2010-01-19 Minutes - Property Standards

Minutes

Property Standards - Etobicoke York Panel

Meeting No.	28	Contact	Brad Bartlett, Committee Secretary
Meeting Date	Tuesday, January 19, 2010	Phone	416-394-5606
Start Time	9:30 AM	E-mail	bbartle@toronto.ca
Location	Council Chamber, Etobicoke Civic Centre

Confirmation of Minutes On motion by Diana Fancher, the Minutes of the meeting of the Property Standards Committee held on December 15, 2009, were confirmed. Martha Marini in the Chair.

SV28.1

ACTION

Adopted

Ward: 1

19 Harlow Crescent - Folder No.: 09 180698 PRS 00 IV

Committee Decision

Property Standards Committee – Etobicoke York Panel:

1. Confirmed the Order to Comply dated October 23, 2009, issued under section 15.2(2) of the Building Code Act, S.O. 1992, Chapter 23, as amended, under Folder No. 180698 PRS 00 IV, by Vaughn Shaw, Property Standards Officer, for 19 Harlow Crescent, Toronto. The time to Comply to the subject Order was extended to February 15, 2010.

Origin

(October 23, 2009) Letter from Francesco Lippa

Summary

Appeal of Order to Comply (October 23, 2009) for 19 Harlow Crescent.

Background Information

Order to Comply (October 23, 2009) for 19 Harlow Crescent
(http://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2010/sv/bgrd/backgroundfile-26187.pdf)
Appeal Letter for 19 Harlow Crescent
(http://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2010/sv/bgrd/backgroundfile-26188.pdf)
Property Survey and Arborist Report from V. Shaw, PSO
Photos from V. Shaw, PSO
Site Sketch from Mr. Lippa
Photos from A. Karczewski, Arborist
Photos from Mr. Lippa - 19 Harlow Crescent
Letter (November 23, 2009) from Mrs. Lippa
Letter (December 24, 2009) from Mr. and Mrs. Lippa
Extract (November 24, 2009) Panel Meeting
(http://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2010/sv/bgrd/backgroundfile-26228.pdf)

Communications

(January 19, 2010) Submission from Adam Karczewski, Arborist Inspector (photographs) (SV.Supp.SV28.1.1)
(January 19, 2010) Submission from Vaughn Shaw, PSO (November 5, 2009 Survey) (SV.Supp.SV28.1.2)
(January 19, 2010) Submission from Frank Lippa (Survey) (SV.Supp.SV28.1.3)

Speakers

(November 24, 2009) Joe Luzi, Supervisor
(November 24, 2009) Vaughn Shaw, PSO
(November 24, 2009) Adam Karczewski, Arborist Inspector
(November 24, 2009) Rick Florio, Representative
(November 24, 2009) Frank Lippa
(January 19, 2010) Joe Luzi, Supervisor
(January 19, 2010) Vaughn Shaw, PSO
(January 19, 2010) Adam Karczewski, Arborist Inspector
(January 19, 2010) Rick Florio, Representative
(January 19, 2010) Frank Lippa

Motions

1 - Motion to Confirm Order moved by Diana Fancher (Carried)

Property Standards Committee – Etobicoke York Panel:

2 - Motion to Nominate a Member moved by Roberta Jennings (Carried)

Property Standards Committee – Etobicoke York Panel:

1. Appointed Barbara Ewles as Acting Chair for Item SV28.1 only.

3 - Motion to Nominate a Member moved by Roberta Jennings (Carried)

Property Standards Committee – Etobicoke York Panel:

1. Appointed Martha Marini as Chair for the remainder of the Agenda.

Declared Interests

The following member(s) declared an interest:

Martha Marini - The Representative, Rick Florio is known to Ms. Marini.

SV28.2

ACTION

Adopted

Ward: 17

2306 Dufferin Street - Folder No.: 09 186031 PRS 00 IV

Committee Decision

Property Standards Committee – Etobicoke York Panel:

1. Confirmed the Order to Comply dated November 6, 2009, issued under section 15.2(2) of the Building Code Act, S.O. 1992, Chapter 23, as amended, under Folder No. 186031 PRS 00 IV, by Karla Zambrano, Property Standards Officer, for 2306 Dufferin Street, Toronto. The time to Comply to the subject Order was extended to July 31, 2010.

2. Directed that the Appellant immediately install a temporary fence on top of the retaining wall for safety reasons, to the satisfaction of the Property Standards Officer.

Origin

(November 20, 2009) Letter from Derrick Clements and Long Ten Liew

Summary

Appeal of Order to Comply (November 6, 2009) for 2306 Dufferin Street.

Background Information

Order to Comply (November 6, 2009) for 2306 Dufferin Street
(http://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2010/sv/bgrd/backgroundfile-26261.pdf)
Appeal Letter for 2306 Dufferin Street
(http://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2010/sv/bgrd/backgroundfile-26262.pdf)
Extract (December 15, 2009) Panel Meeting
(http://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2010/sv/bgrd/backgroundfile-26263.pdf)

Communications

(January 19, 2010) Submission from Karla Zambrano, PSO (photographs) (SV.Supp.SV28.2.1)

Speakers

(December 15, 2009) Kimberley Kilburn, Supervisor
(December 15, 2009) Karla Zambrano, PSO
(January 19, 2010) Kimberley Kilburn, Supervisor
(January 19, 2010) Karla Zambrano, PSO
(January 19, 2010) Derrick Clements

Motions

1 - Motion to Confirm Order moved by Roberta Jennings (Carried)

Property Standards Committee – Etobicoke York Panel:

2. Directed that the Appellant immediately install a temporary fence on top of the retaining wall for safety reasons, to the satisfaction of the Property Standards Officer.

SV28.3

ACTION

Adopted

2080 Dufferin Street - Folder No.: 09 179198 PRS 00 IV

Committee Decision

Property Standards Committee – Etobicoke York Panel:

1. Confirmed the Order to Comply dated October 22, 2009, issued under section 15.2(2) of the Building Code Act, S.O. 1992, Chapter 23, as amended, under Folder No. 179198 PRS 00 IV, by Karla Zambrano, Property Standards Officer, for 2080 Dufferin Street, Toronto. The time to Comply to the subject Order was extended to August 31, 2010.

2. Directed that the Appellant immediately install temporary fencing, for safety reasons, to the satisfaction of the Property Standards Officer.

Origin

(December 4, 2009) Letter from Troy Williams, The Israelite Nation World Wide Ministries

Summary

Appeal of Order to Comply (October 22, 2009) for 2080 Dufferin Street.

Background Information

Order to Comply (October 22, 2009) for 2080 Dufferin Street
(http://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2010/sv/bgrd/backgroundfile-26231.pdf)
Appeal Letter for 2080 Dufferin Street
(http://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2010/sv/bgrd/backgroundfile-26232.pdf)

Communications

(January 19, 2010) Submission from Karla Zambrano, PSO (photographs) (SV.Supp.SV28.3.1)

Speakers

(January 19, 2010) Kimberley Kilburn, Supervisor
(January 19, 2010) Karla Zambrano, PSO
(January 19, 2010) Troy Williams

Motions

1 - Motion to Confirm Order moved by Roberta Jennings (Carried)

Property Standards Committee – Etobicoke York Panel:

2. Directed that the Appellant immediately install temporary fencing, for safety reasons, to the satisfaction of the Property Standards Officer.

SV28.4

ACTION

Adopted

Ward: 17

2090 Dufferin Street

Committee Decision

Property Standards Committee – Etobicoke York Panel:

1. Amended Items 1 to 3, of the Order to Comply, issued under section 15.2(2) of the Building Code Act, S.O. 1992, Chapter 23, as amended, by Karla Zambrano, Property Standards Officer, for 2090 Dufferin Street, Toronto, to state that the Location is the, “South Side of Property.”

2. Confirmed the Order to Comply dated November 18, 2009, issued under section 15.2(2) of the Building Code Act, S.O. 1992, Chapter 23, as amended, by Karla Zambrano, Property Standards Officer, for 2090 Dufferin Street, Toronto. The time to Comply to the subject Order was extended to August 31, 2010.

3. Directed that the Appellant immediately install a temporary fence on top of the retaining wall for safety reasons, to the satisfaction of the Property Standards Officer.

Origin

(December 7, 2009) Letter from Alexander Drumonde

Summary

Appeal of Order to Comply (November 18, 2009) for 2090 Dufferin Street.

Background Information

Order to Comply (November 18, 2009) for 2090 Dufferin Street
(http://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2010/sv/bgrd/backgroundfile-26233.pdf)
Appeal Letter for 2090 Dufferin Street
(http://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2010/sv/bgrd/backgroundfile-26234.pdf)

Communications

(January 19, 2010) Submission from Karla Zambrano, PSO (photographs) (SV.Supp.SV28.4.1)

Speakers

(January 19, 2010) Kimberley Kilburn, Supervisor
(January 19, 2010) Karla Zambrano, PSO
(January 19, 2010) Alexander Drumonde

Motions

1 - Motion to Confirm Order moved by Barbara Ewles (Carried)

Property Standards Committee – Etobicoke York Panel:

3. Directed that the Appellant immediately install a temporary fence on top of the retaining wall for safety reasons, to the satisfaction of the Property Standards Officer.

SV28.5

ACTION

Adopted

Ward: 5

8 Kings Point Drive, Unit 11 - Folder No.: 09195399 PRS 00 IV

Committee Decision

Property Standards Committee – Etobicoke York Panel:

1. Confirmed the Order to Comply dated December 14, 2009, issued under section 15.2(2) of the Building Code Act, S.O. 1992, Chapter 23, as amended, under Folder No. 195399 PRS 00 IV, by Stephen Shumelda, Property Standards Officer, for 8 Kings Point Drive, Unit 11, Toronto. The time to Comply to the subject Order was extended to May 31, 2010.

Origin

(December 18, 2009) Letter from Oscar Gutt, Sigma Canada Inc.

Summary

Appeal of Order to Comply (December 14, 2009) for 8 Kings Point Drive, Unit 11.

Background Information

Order to Comply (December 14, 2009) for 8 Kings Point Drive, Unit 11
(http://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2010/sv/bgrd/backgroundfile-26237.pdf)
Appeal Letter for 8 Kings Point Drive, Unit 11
(http://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2010/sv/bgrd/backgroundfile-26238.pdf)

Communications

(January 19, 2010) Submission from Stephen Shumelda, PSO (photograph) (SV.Supp.SV28.5.1)

Speakers

(January 19, 2010) Kimberley Kilburn, Supervisor
(January 19, 2010) Stephen Shumelda, PSO
(January 19, 2010) Oscar Gutt, Sigma Canada Inc.
(January 19, 2010) James Forfar, Superintendent
(January 19, 2010) Jiri Matras
(January 19, 2010) David Sivar, Interpreter

Motions

1 - Motion to Confirm Order moved by Barbara Ewles (Carried)

Property Standards Committee – Etobicoke York Panel:

SV28.6

ACTION

Deferred

Ward: 5

12 Statler Avenue - Folder No.: 09 194647 PRS 00 IV

Committee Decision

Property Standards Committee – Etobicoke York Panel:

1. Deferred consideration the matter of an appeal against an Order to Comply dated December 8, 2009, issued under section 15.2(2) of the Building Code Act, S.O. 1992, Chapter 23, as amended, under Folder No. 09 194647 PRS 00 IV, by Orlando Donato, Property Standards Officer, for 12 Statler Avenue, to its March 23, 2010 meeting.

Origin

(January 14, 2010) Letter from Michael and Theresa Ane Czich

Summary

Appeal of Order to Comply (December 8, 2009) for 12 Statler Avenue.

Background Information

Order to Comply (December 8, 2009) for 12 Statler Avenue
(http://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2010/sv/bgrd/backgroundfile-26240.pdf)
Appeal Letter for 12 Statler Avenue
(http://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2010/sv/bgrd/backgroundfile-26241.pdf)

Communications

(January 15, 2010) Letter from Michael and Teresa Czich (SV.Supp.SV28.6.1)

Speakers

(January 19, 2010) Kimberley Kilburn, Supervisor
(January 19, 2010) Orlando Donato, PSO

Motions

1 - Motion to Defer Item moved by Barbara Ewles (Carried)

Property Standards Committee – Etobicoke York Panel:

____________________________________

Chair

Tuesday, January 19, 2010


Meeting Sessions

Session Date	Session Type	Start Time	End Time	Public or Closed Session
2010-01-19	Morning	9:30 AM	11:35 AM	Public


Attendance
Members were present for some or all of the time period indicated.

Date and Time	Quorum	Members
2010-01-19 9:30 AM - 11:35 AM (Public Session)	Present	Present: Ewles, Fancher, Jennings, Marini (Chair)